A Tipperary man’s prison term for animal cruelty offences was increased from four months to six months, at Clonmel Circuit Court of Appeals, on Tuesday 25th June 2024.
The man, from Burncourt, Cahir, Co. Tipperary had lodged an appeal against the severity of a sentence previously imposed at Cashel District Court in January, when Judge Brian O’Shea sentenced him to four months imprisonment, and banned him for life from having a dog. The man’s wife, was also convicted, fined €400 and disqualified for 10 years from having dogs, save for one dog which she already had in her possession.
ISPCA Senior Inspector Alice Lacey told the court of making two visits to the defendant’s home, the first on Wednesday 10th August 2022. On that occasion, 13 dogs – including a Belgian Malinois, a Belgian Shepherd, a Springer Spaniel, a Beagle, and a number of terriers – were found living in small, rundown pens or confined on chains, some on very short chains.
Many of the dogs were malnourished and an array of ailments were detected including skin conditions, lice infestation, and dental disease. Three Kerry blue terriers were in particularly bad condition and one female wire-haired terrier was found to be pregnant. The odour emanating from some of the dogs’ coats and skin was described as putrid. Despite the fact that it was a very warm day, some dogs were without access to drinking water. All of the dogs were surrendered into ISPCA care.
On a subsequent visit on Thursday 16th March 2023, a further 10 dogs – two Springer Spaniels, a hairy Whippet, a Cocker Spaniel and a number of terriers – were found in sub-standard and dirty living conditions. Many ailments were again noted including mange, alopecia, conjunctivitis of the eyes, dental disease and matted, dirty coats. One dog had a horrific, untreated lower jaw injury and another was of extremely poor body weight. All of these dogs were also removed.
After hearing the evidence, Judge Catherine Staines commented: “This was extremely serious. These dogs suffered. No proper food, water, emaciated and in pain”. “Animals are defenceless” she added. Judge Staines affirmed the original District Court order, and imposed an additional two-month prison term, with both sentences to run consecutively.
Commenting after the case, Senior Inspector Lacey said: “These dogs endured unnecessary suffering at the hands of someone who should have been there to protect them. The affirmation of the initial District Court order handed down in January this year, together with the additional two-month sentence, was welcomed. This case has come full circle. From the rescuing of these dogs and the seeking of justice that ensued, to the significant and warranted outcome”.
Please continue to report any animal welfare concerns to the ISPCA’s National Animal Cruelty Helpline on 0818 515 515, report online at: https://ispca.ie/report-cruelty/ or email [email protected].
ISPCA Animal Welfare Inspectors continue to work tirelessly to remove animals from terrible situations, just like this one. A kind donation will help the ISPCA continue our vital rescue work and care for many more neglected, abused, and cruelly treated animals. If you can, donate online today.
